How to reply to a bad review without making it worse
Research on replies to negative reviews shows which words build future guests’ trust and which words undermine it.
A bad review happens to every host. Less well known is that a future guest reading a negative review does not judge only what happened, but at least as much how the host replied to it. That is also good news: a reply to a bad review is one of the few situations where you have a chance to partly restore lost trust – or lose it for good.
A reply itself already builds trust
A study that tested how future guests judge negative reviews with an accompanying reply from the property showed something clear: the mere presence of a reply – compared with silence – raises perceived trust and the feeling that the property truly cares about guests. In addition, a reply that was personal and sent quickly consistently worked better than a late or generic one.
Which words work, and which ones harm
Another study tested five different strategies for responding to a negative review: personalisation (addressing the specific person and situation), empathy, admitting a mistake, denial and excuse. The findings are unambiguous: personalisation, empathy and admitting a mistake raise future guests’ trust, while denial and excuses lower it. So – “this is not true” or “this happened for a reason that was not our fault” on average harms more than it would if the host simply admitted the mistake and said what they had fixed.
A newer finding is also interesting: speed of reply is not always equally important. For reviews that are emotional and subjective (“I felt uncomfortable”), a fast reply works better. For reviews that state concrete facts (“the heater did not work”, “there was no hot water”), future guests value a thoughtful, more detailed reply more, even if it comes a little later.
What this means for you
- Always reply, even if the review is unfair. Future guests take silence worse than even a clumsily worded reply.
- Address the specific situation; do not write a generic template that would fit any review. Future guests notice the difference.
- Admit what is true, and say what you have changed. That builds trust more than a defence or looking for an excuse.
- For emotional complaints, reply quickly and with understanding; for factual, concrete criticisms, take time for an accurate, clear reply.
Where Foli can help
Foli does not write replies to reviews for you – that part stays personal, and personality is exactly what the research says counts most. It does help prevent smaller problems from building up into a review: during the stay the guest can report a problem at once through their link, instead of you first hearing about it from a review when it is already too late to put right. Routine messages (confirmations, directions, reminders) go out automatically, so if a bad review does arrive you still have time for a thoughtful reply, not only a quick reaction among other tasks.
A bad review is not the end of the story for a future guest – it is often only the beginning of how they judge whether they can trust you.
Foli · Zala Rosa d.o.o. · Metelkova ulica 15, 1000 Ljubljana · [email protected] · www.hellofoli.com